Share

Foley, Foley & Pearson News

Friday, July 21, 2017

Tell the World When you are Doing Business as a Limited Liabilty Company

If you are doing business as a limited liability company (LLC) and have not clearly let people know that you are operating as an LLC, you could lose the liability protection that LLCs were intended to provide.

The Alaska Supreme Court recently ruled in the case of Daggett v. Feeney, Supreme Court Opinion 7179 (June 16, 2017), that a couple who operated a contracting business was personally liable for the debts of the company because they failed to disclose to the customer that the contractor was doing business as a limited liability company.  Here were the facts.

James and Nadia Daggett set up Daggett, LLC, but they operated under the trade name Alaskan Wind Industries (AWI). The Daggetts were the sole members of the LLC.  They advertised that AWI was a renewable energy contractor that sold and installed wind turbines for home energy generation.

The Daggetts, under the name of AWI entered into a contract with Richard Feeney to install a wind turbine on Feeney’s property in Homer.  Daggett, LLC did not appear on the contracting documents.  Feeney made a down payment of $32,850 to purchase the turbine and the Daggetts began work by digging a foundation for the turbine and ordering the turbine from a turbine supplier in California. 

A problem arose when Feeney learned that the wind turbine would violate a neighborhood land covenant that prohibited structures over 35-feet tall.  The turbine would have been 49-feet tall.  Feeney asked the Daggetts to stop work and terminated the contract.  Eventually a lawsuit was filed by Feeney to get a refund of the down payment.  Feeney won a damage award of $23,250, a partial return of the down payment, plus interest costs and attorney fees which pushed the final award to over $36,000.

The Daggetts claimed that AWI was the trade name for Daggett, LLC and therefore they were not personally liable for the damages.  The general rule is that members (owners) of an LLC are not liable for the debts of an LLC.  But in this case the court concluded that the Daggetts had failed to disclose to Feeney in the contract that AWI was the trade name for Daggett, LLC and that AWI was a “dba” for Daggett, LLC.  The court concluded that the Daggetts had acted as “agents of an undisclosed principal” (Daggett LLC), when they entered into the contract with Feeney and began performing the work.  In other words, the Daggetts were held liable as “agents” of Daggett, LLC not as “owners” of Daggett, LLC because they failed to disclose to Feeney that AWI was the tradename of Daggett, LLC.  This might seem like a subtle difference, but often it is the nuances of the law the people fail to appreciate.

So how might this affect your business?  If you are operating as a corporation or LLC, you should make that clear to the public and anyone who you are doing business with.  Business owners should clearly indicate that they are organized as an LLC on marketing materials, business cards, website, contracts, invoices, letterhead or any other materials which identify the business. 

Some people want to set up an LLC with one or more subsidiary trade names.  For instance a company might be called Alaska Touring, LLC doing business as Alaska Mountaintop Tours, Alaska River Tours and Alaska Ocean Tours.  If owners of this company do not disclose to the public or the customers that Alaska Mountaintop Tours, Alaska River Tours and Alaska Ocean Tours are trade names for Alaska Touring, LLC, those owners could be liable for contractual or tort liability as agents for an undisclosed principal under the Alaska Supreme Court reasoning in Daggett v. Feeney.  This case may also suggest that perhaps it is better not to have a trade name or dba attached to an LLC.  In order to enjoy the protections of the LLC form of business it is probably best to do business in the name of the LLC.  If there are multiple business forms, it might be best to set up additional LLCs.





© 2017 Foley, Foley & Pearson, P.C. | Disclaimer
4300 B Street, Suite 400, Anchorage, AK 99503
| Phone: 907-522-2272

About Us | Our Services | Newsletters | Generations

Attorney Website Platform by
Zola Creative


Foley, Foley & Pearson, P.C. is a full service Estate Planning law firm. We offer our clients services in Probate Administration, Estate Taxes, Wills, Trusts, Disability and Incapacity Planning, Estate Administration, Corporate and Business Law, Business Succession Planning, and Planned Giving and Charitable Bequests.